On 20 April 2020, the May West Texas Intermediate crude contract on NYMEX settled below zero. That had not happened since those futures began trading in 1983. The U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission recorded a fall from $17.73 to a settlement of −$37.63 that day, a drop of $55.36, on the last full session before the contract expired. The Energy Information Administration put the intraday low at about −$40.32 around 2:30 p.m. Eastern.

That print does not mean crude oil itself had become worthless. Filling stations were still selling fuel, and physical barrels still had a use. What went negative was one futures contract, one day from expiry, with a physical-delivery obligation attached.

A NYMEX WTI contract is physically settled. Anyone still long after the last trading day is expected to take delivery of crude at Cushing, Oklahoma, unless other arrangements have already been made. Most traders never intend to do that. The EIA notes that only about 1% of futures contracts actually go to delivery. In a normal month, anyone who does not want the barrels closes or rolls the position well before expiry.

April 2020 was not a normal month. Lockdowns had crushed fuel demand. In the week ending 17 April, U.S. refinery runs were 24% below a year earlier, according to the EIA. Cushing's tanks held about 60 million barrels against 76 million barrels of working storage capacity. What storage remained was expensive. Traders who could not take delivery had to sell the May contract, and the few counterparties who could store oil were able to name the price. When the remaining bids come from people who will only take the barrels if they are paid to do so, the print can fall below zero: the seller pays the buyer to take the contract.

The episode was also narrower than the headlines suggested. Daily WTI spot prices published by FRED show $18.31 on Friday 17 April, −$36.98 on Monday 20 April, and $8.91 on 21 April. Brent, a seaborne crude without the same Cushing delivery bottleneck, never followed. Its FRED spot low in those weeks was $9.12 on 21 April. The EIA judged that negative prices were likely confined to the financial market, with few physical sellers paying to dispose of oil.

In principle it can happen again, for any physically delivered contract, if storage near the delivery point is tight and holders cannot take the commodity. That is why many retail platforms now close or roll positions days before expiry. A long futures position can lose more than the cash posted as margin; April 2020 made that literal, because the loss exceeded the full contract value. Anyone using a futures-based oil fund should also check how and when that fund rolls, because a steep gap between the expiring month and the next one is costly.

This is an explanation of a settlement, not a trade idea. The figures above come from the CFTC statement on the May 2020 WTI contract and from the EIA. A longer write-up of the same numbers is in How Did WTI Crude Oil Futures Go Negative in April 2020?