Before choosing between tree-care estimates, ask each company to describe the same desired outcome in writing and explain what its price includes. Differences in access, debris removal, stump work, and assumptions can make two estimates difficult to compare even when they refer to the same tree.
Start by identifying the tree and describing your goal, such as clearance over a roof or removal of a particular tree. Ask an arborist to assess the situation and recommend an appropriate scope; a homeowner’s request for an estimate does not establish what work the tree needs.
The International Society of Arboriculture (ISA), in its consumer guidance on hiring an arborist, recommends obtaining multiple estimates, checking credentials and insurance, and examining written specifications rather than automatically accepting the lowest bid. The questions below turn that advice into a comparison you can use before signing.
What do two different estimates actually cover?
Imagine a homeowner requests removal of one backyard tree. Both companies have seen the property, but their written estimates describe different jobs. Company A proposes removal of the tree, leaves the stump and cut wood on site, and assumes a clear route through a side gate. Company B proposes removal, hauling the wood and branches, and arranging stump grinding; its estimate assumes access through a neighbor’s driveway.
Neither scope is automatically better. A homeowner who wants firewood and has a practical plan for the stump might prefer Company A’s scope. Someone who wants the material hauled away and the stump addressed might prefer Company B’s. The key question is what each company would charge for the homeowner’s chosen outcome, with access confirmed.
Ask both companies for a revised estimate or separate written line items for the same requested work. If one cannot provide a particular service, ask what is excluded and who would arrange it. Avoid treating an unspecified item as included simply because the other estimate mentions it.
Before comparing totals, mark each line as included, excluded, conditional, or unanswered. An unanswered item is not a confirmed exclusion or a promise of free work. Return it to the company as a question, then keep the response with the estimate.
Question | Company A: hypothetical scope | Company B: hypothetical scope | Follow-up before comparing
Tree work | Remove the identified tree | Remove the identified tree | Confirm both mean the same tree and extent of removal.
Wood and branches | Leave cut material on site | Haul material away | Request the same disposal option or a separate price.
Stump | Left in place | Grinding arranged | Clarify grinding details and treatment of resulting material.
Access | Clear side gate assumed | Neighbor’s driveway assumed | Confirm the route is workable and any permission is obtained.
Unknown conditions | Not specified | Not specified | Ask when work pauses and how additional charges are approved.
How specific should the work description be?
Specific enough that you and the crew can identify what was agreed. For pruning, ask the arborist to identify the tree, the purpose of the work, the relevant areas, and the intended result in language you understand. Phrases such as “trim tree” or “make safe” leave room for different expectations; ask what those phrases mean for this particular job.
For removal, ask whether the price covers the whole identified tree, what remains at ground level, and whether the stump is included. If stump grinding is proposed, ask how the work area and finished condition will be described, what happens to grindings, and whether restoration or filling is included. Do not assume grinding and site restoration are the same service.
If the estimates recommend different work, ask each arborist to explain the reason and the trade-offs. A different recommendation may reflect a different assessment or goal, not merely a pricing difference. You can seek another professional opinion if you do not understand the proposed scope or its implications.
Which access assumptions can change the job?
Ask each company to identify its proposed route for equipment and material, the space it expects to use, and anything it needs you to arrange. Mention narrow gates, fences, landscaping, parked vehicles, irrigation features, and areas where access is restricted. Ask whether the estimate depends on moving or protecting any of them, who will do that, and what happens if the planned route is unavailable on the day.
If a route crosses a neighbor’s property, do not treat access as settled until the appropriate permission is secured. Ask the company what access it needs and whether the neighbor should receive a description of the proposed use. If permission is refused, request a revised plan and price before accepting the estimate.
Discuss protection and possible damage in concrete terms: what precautions are proposed for the driveway, lawn, and nearby features, and how would damage be documented and addressed? Photograph existing conditions if useful, and make sure any promises about protection or repair appear in the written agreement.
What counts as cleanup?
Ask where branches, logs, chips, and other resulting material will go. “Cleanup included” may mean different things to different people: one homeowner may expect everything hauled away, while another wants usable wood left in a specified location. State your preference and ask the provider to describe the agreed result.
Clarify whether the crew will leave wood in manageable pieces, whether chips or stump grindings remain, and whether moving material elsewhere on the property is included. If you plan to keep material, agree on the location and any size expectations beforehand. For a separate disposal provider, establish who is responsible for arranging collection and what happens if collection is delayed.
TreeWorkGuide also has a separate guide on when to prune Texas oaks, including timing pruning around oak wilt risk.
What insurance and credential documentation should you request?
Ask each company for proof of insurance and the insurer’s contact details, then follow ISA’s advice to call the insurance company. Ask what coverage applies to the proposed work, including liability and workers’ compensation where applicable, and whether the documentation will be current when the work is scheduled. A document alone does not answer every coverage question; direct questions about terms, exclusions, and the insured parties to the insurer.
If subcontractors will perform any part of the job, ask who they are and how their coverage will be verified. Insurance requirements and arrangements vary by jurisdiction and circumstances, so ask the insurer or an appropriately qualified local adviser about any uncertainty rather than assuming a particular document guarantees coverage.
Ask for the name and credential of the person responsible for the assessment and who will supervise the work. ISA provides a directory for locating and verifying ISA credentials. An individual’s credential is useful information, but still compare the actual scope, references, insurance, and written agreement. Ask the company about any local permits or licenses relevant to the job and who will obtain them.
How should the estimate handle surprises?
Ask which conditions are assumed and which could change the price or schedule. For example, the planned access route might prove unavailable, or the provider might discover a condition that warrants reassessment. Ask the company to explain likely decision points without promising that every possible issue can be predicted in advance.
Agree on a change process: who will contact you, how the proposed change and its cost will be described, and whether work affected by the change will pause until you authorize it. Provide a contact method for the workday. If you cannot be reached, ask what the crew will do and whether any additional charge would require your approval.
Check the estimate’s validity period, proposed scheduling, payment terms, and cancellation or postponement provisions. Before signing, reconcile verbal promises with the written contract. Keep the estimate, any revisions, insurance information, and approved changes together so that everyone can refer to the same terms.
What message can you send both companies?
Send the same core request to each provider, then add questions specific to its proposal:
“Thank you for the estimate. To help me compare the proposed work, please confirm in writing: which tree and work are included; the planned access route and any permissions or preparation needed; what happens to branches, wood, chips, and the stump; and any site protection or restoration included. Please also identify any subcontractors, provide current insurance documentation and insurer contact details, and explain how you handle unexpected conditions, price changes, and my approval. If possible, please price the following options separately: [list options].”
When the replies arrive, compare the agreed scope and the remaining conditions alongside the price. If a key answer is unclear, ask for it to be incorporated into a revised estimate or contract before deciding.
Sources
- Why Hire an Arborist? — ISA Trees Are Good consumer brochure
- Find an ISA-Credentialed Arborist — Trees Are Good
- Source for: ISA provides a directory for locating and verifying ISA credentials.
Responses (0)